Kaguraoka Munetada Shrine – Celebrating 160 Years of Enshrinement (May 2022)
Kaguraoka Munetada Shrine – Celebrating 160 Years of Enshrinement
Kurozumi Munemichi, the Seventh Chief Patriarch
May 2022
On the 25th day of the 2nd month of Bunkyū 2 (1862, lunar calendar), which corresponds to March 25 in today’s calendar—the season of cherry blossoms—the Munetada Shrine at Kaguraoka 神楽岡・宗忠神社 in Kyoto was enshrined.
In the turbulent years of the late Tokugawa period, only five years before the Meiji Restoration 明治維新 (1868), it was designated by Emperor Kōmei (r. 1848-1867) as the sole imperial prayer site, where daily petitions for the protection of the nation were offered. Among the offerings were: a large scroll inscribed “Munetada Daimyōjin 宗忠大明神” (Great Illustrious Divine Munetada) by Chancellor Kujō Hisatada; an autograph by Chancellor Nijō Narinaga, the last Chancellor and regent to the young Emperor Meiji, stating “In the summer of Bunkyū 2, I copied the teaching poem of the Divine Founder Munetada and dedicated it to the shrine”; and a pledge of faith titled Shinmon no Koto 神文之事 (“Re: the Divine Pledge”) by Prince Sanjō Sanetomi, later one of the great statesmen of Meiji.
These three men were all among the most important court nobles serving Emperor Kōmei, renowned in history. Chancellors Kujō and Nijō advocated union of court and shogunate, believing the nation must not be divided in the face of the advancing Western powers. Prince Sanjō, on the other hand, strongly promoted expulsion of foreigners, serving as spiritual support for the young loyalist samurai of Chōshū and Tosa. To anyone familiar with the era, it is astonishing that figures of such utterly opposing principles all openly declared their faith in Munetada Daimyōjin.
Even amid that time of upheaval, one of the greatest turning points—indispensable when speaking of the eve of the Restoration—was the “Kinmon Incident 禁門の変 (Hamaguri Gate Incident 蛤御門の変).” As a bonus, anyone who knows its outline can enjoy films, dramas, and novels set in that era all the more. So, relying on my old reference book from my student days, I would like to trace its summary.
The Kinmon Incident took place on the 19th day of the 7th month of Genji 1 (1864, lunar calendar), near the Imperial Palace in Kyoto, when the Chōshū domain clashed militarily with the shogunate forces. Because the fighting occurred near Kinmon 禁門 that means the palace gates, it was called the “Kinmon Incident,” and since the fiercest battle was at the Hamaguri Gate 蛤御門, it is also known as the “Hamaguri Gate Incident.”
As the leading domain of the sonnō jōi 尊皇攘夷 (Revere the Emperor, Expel the Foreigners) faction, Chōshū had gained strong influence at court through figures such as Prince Sanjō Sanetomi. In opposition, the Satsuma and Aizu domains, supporting union of court and shogunate, plotted a coup to expel Chōshū from Kyoto. This was the Coup d’État of the 18th Day of the Eighth Month in Bunkyū 3 (1863), which drove Chōshū from power and forced Sanjō and six other radical nobles into exile.
Yet some Chōshū samurai remained hidden in Kyoto, repeatedly meeting with other sonnō jōi activists to restore their strength. Shinsengumi 新撰組 (the special police force of Kyoto) discovered this, and the largest purge was the Ikedaya Incident 池田屋事件, in which many Chōshū and allied activists lost their lives. Afterward, Chōshū gathered troops, claiming to petition Emperor Kōmei against false charges on their lord, but their demands were rejected. The radical faction then rose in arms to overthrow the court‑shogunate alliance by force—this was the Kinmon Incident.
Near the Hamaguri Gate of the Imperial Palace, the Chōshū domain clashed with the Aizu and Kuwana domains in fierce fighting. At one point, Chōshū forces even pressed into the Nakadachiuri Gate within the palace grounds. Yet when the Satsuma domain arrived as reinforcements for the shogunate side, the tide turned, and Chōshū was defeated.
In this conflict, most of the sonnō jōi leaders of Chōshū—including Kusaka Genzui—lost their lives. Because Chōshū forces had fired toward the Imperial Palace, the domain was declared an enemy of the throne, its lord was placed under an order of pursuit, and the shogunate dispatched an expeditionary army to subjugate Chōshū.
Although they were loyalists devoted to the Emperor, the reason Chōshū activists fired toward the Imperial Palace can be understood as an extreme measure intended to persuade Emperor Kōmei to leave the palace for his safety. There was precedent for moving to Mount Hiei 比叡山, yet Emperor Kōmei did not stir at all, and specialists still leave the reason unclear.
Professor Shibata Minoru of Kyoto University once remarked in lecture: “History forbids ‘if,’ but had the Emperor left the palace then, Kyoto would have been reduced to ashes.” This was heard by the Sixth Chief Patriarch during his student days. In the end, Chōshū was defeated by Satsuma’s elite troops and branded an enemy of the throne. For Chōshū, the Emperor’s refusal to move was a fatal and unforeseen outcome.
It may not serve as academic proof that divine judgment (mikuji 神籤)—the “will of Heaven”—directly determined the Emperor’s actions. Yet when Lord Kushida Sakon Shōgen of the Nijō family rode swiftly up to Kaguraoka Munetada Shrine to inquire, “What is the will of Munetada Daimyōjin?” the fervent prayer of High Disciple Akagi Tadaharu, a senior disciple, brought forth the response: “His Majesty must not leave the Palace!” This reply is hoped to be recognized as the answer to the still‑unresolved historical question of why Emperor Kōmei remained within the Palace.
In any case, we who trust and revere the Divine Founder Munetada (Daimyōjin) as companions in the Way should, at this ten‑year milestone of Kaguraoka Munetada Shrine, renew our inspiration by reflecting on these points. We look forward with anticipation to the commemorative festival on October 16, five months hence, and to offering our worship.
Last year’s NHK historical drama Reach Beyond the Blue Sky (Seiten o Tsuke) featured as its first‑half climax the great turning point in the youth of Shibusawa Eiichi (1840–1931 Father of Japanese capitalism)—the Kinmon Incident. Likewise, in last year’s widely discussed film Rurouni Kenshin: The Final Chapter, the decisive event that shifted the stage from Kyoto to a hidden refuge was also the Kinmon Incident.
May the pandemic subside, so that together—young and old, men and women alike—we may offer purification rites at Kaguraoka Munetada Shrine.
拍手
Two claps
Japanese original
https://kurozumikyo.com/michi/2022/05/202205michi
Comments
Post a Comment